Let’s Go There: Wine vs. White Claw
When it comes to flavor, soul, and yep, even calories — wine’s still got it, baby.
By Sarah Hoffman
August 26, 2020
During the summer of 2019 as we were building Maker the market for hard seltzers absolutely exploded. This Summer of Seltzer proved to have staying power; Nielsen dubbed spiked seltzer the most resilient alcohol segment in the U.S. in 2020. Its growth only increased during the pandemic; spiked seltzers reached $1 billion in sales from March 7 to May 30, compared to $1.5 billion in all of 2019. In March and April 2020 hard seltzer buyers decreased their share of spending on beer (5.6 points) and wine (4 points), compared with the same months in 2019, and our own survey data also shows that hard seltzer is directly taking share from wine.
And I’ll admit, as a budding young 20-wait-make-that-30-something, I was seduced by the siren song of the seltzer as well. Just 100 calories, light, and refreshing, it promises a guilt-free social buzz.
So as a card-carrying millennial who gets the appeal and as a wine lover ripping my hair out, I decided to take a closer look.
Spoiler alert, wine wins.
Bang for your Buzz
I’m going for the jugular. Spiked seltzers are not that low cal. While the big, boxed, “100 calorie” on the front of the can is alluring, wine has roughly 2.5x the alcohol of spiked seltzers (5% ABV for spiked seltzer vs. 11-15% ABV for wine). Here’s the true comparison of the “single drink” equivalent of wine vs. spiked seltzer.
A standard not-to-be-named spiked seltzer: 100 calories for 12 oz. 2 grams carbs / sugars.
A standard glass of white wine: 120 calories for 5 oz. 4 g carbs, < 2 grams sugar (Wine Spectator)
So yes, ~20 more calories per “drink” for wine, with comparable carbs and sugar. 20 calories is less than your average carrot. So eat one less chip and have a gorgeous glass of wine.
Wine’s got “bang for your buzz.” And while the point of drinking isn’t the ease to getting boozed up, I’m willing to bet that’s what the claw crew is after. On average, “tastes like nothing” spiked seltzer drinkers consume 2.8 cans per sitting. So if you’re looking for a nice social buzz without consuming 36 oz of flavored malt liquor, wine is here for you.
White Claw’s tagline is “Made Pure,” presenting it as a healthy alternative to wine or beer. Hate to burst your bubble, it ain’t craft vodka and pure sparkling water. Spiked seltzer is typically malt liquor or fermented cane sugar with added artificial fruit flavors (no real black cherries were harmed in the making of your beverage).
And even if this was high quality booze, no alcoholic beverages are health beverages. Wine is having its own reckoning with marketing-driven “clean wine” brands claiming to be a healthy alternative to traditional wine, when their products are not any “healthier” or “more natural” than (and in fact don’t live up to the standard of) wines from high quality small producers.
Other words thrown out to describe these drinks include keto-friendly (check out our Keto Wine Guide), gluten-free, and vegan — guess what, the vast majority of WINE IS ALL THESE THINGS TOO.
We’ve established that alcoholic beverages are not a health drink, they are an indulgence, a delicious, treat-yo-self end to the day. So, in the words of Joey Tribianni, “If you’re going to do something wrong, do it right.”
When you purchase White Claw you are supporting billionaire Anthony von Mandl, who has made it his life’s mission to “bring booze to bros” as the maker of Mike’s Hard Lemonade and now spiked Seltzer.
Wine’s got soul, baby. When you purchase high quality wine from local wineries you are supporting artists — small producers who have made this beverage their craft and life’s work. Each glass reflects a time and place, and is made from real fruit with natural ingredients (no, “natural lime” doesn’t count).
If you NEED the absolute lowest cal option, buy craft vodka from your local distillery and pair with sparkling water. You’ll be supporting a small biz and may even feel a little bit better in the morning.
And if you love being able to throw a can in your bag on the way to the park, try premium canned wine instead. All the convenience, none of the crap. Let’s make 2021 a canned wine summer.
Recommended for you
They make it.
Maker partners with best-in-class small producers that know how to craft a damn-fine wine.
We can it.
We can the wine side-by-side with our winemaker partners, directly from their winery.
You drink it.
We’ll deliver Maker cans and their stories to your door in under 48 hours in California.